It would seem self-evident that an applicant for a job
should be scrupulously honest. First, it
is the right thing to do. Secondly, in
our digital era, one’s academic record can be accessed back to
kindergarten. Yet, many applicants will embellish
their credentials or claim a skill level that may exceed reality. Thirty years ago, I was applying for my first
job in New Jersey after completing my 2 year gastroenterology (GI) fellowship. I was not competent to perform ERCP, a
complex scope examination that GI practices desperately still want to add to their
practices' skill sets. Yet, I was advised by a
practicing GI physician to simply claim that I could do the procedure. Otherwise, he said, they would simply pass me by. I queried the
practitioner on my proposed course of action after being hired if I were
summoned to perform an ERCP. Decades
later, I do not recall his response. I
can imagine what my new employer’s response might have been upon discovering that I had misrepresented my skills..
Should Applicants or Employers Take a Polygraph?
How honest should an interviewer be with a job applicant? On the
day that I wrote this, I read of a technique where an interviewer who is
meeting a job applicant at a restaurant, secretly arranges for the applicant’s
meal to be messed up in some way. The justification
is to see how the applicant reacts in real time to an unforeseen and unfavorable event. It reminds me of my initial interview at NYU
School of Medicine, when the interviewer, among other slippery questions, asked
me “what is the death rate?” The
correct answer, which I luckily knew, is 100%.
Perhaps, this demonstration of my nimble intellect explains why they
accepted me.
I do not support subterfuge in a job interview to gauge
applicants’ behaviors. It’s certainly
fair game to present hypotheticals, but outright trickery should be out of
bounds. And, if an interviewer is
overtly dishonest, can this person be trusted after the hire? If we sanction employer legerdemain,
then should we not permit the applicant to play tricks on the interviewer to gauge
his or her behavior and the company’s culture?
I’ve always played it straight. It’s all I know. As for the position in New Jersey referenced above, I didn't get the job. And, so my life in Cleveland began.
Comments
Post a Comment