The Korean War Veterans Memorial, one of the most moving memorials I've ever seen, is introduced by stark words of enormous power and meaning: Freedom is Not Free.
Many Washington, D.C. license tags are adorned with the the words, Taxation Without Representation, a demonstration of citizen protest that is unthinkable in so many other world nations.
I recall years ago, when a protest developed when the Smithsonian Institution included a written description in an exhibit of the Enola Gay, the small airplane that dropped a heavy payload on Hiroshima on August 6, 1945. After vehement protests from American veterans and others, the words were withdrawn.
The United States Supreme Court heard and read many words a few weeks ago on the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, affectionately and derisively referred to as Obamacare. The Court heard extended arguments over a 3 day span, a marked departure from the brief period of time usually allotted for oral arguments.
After those 3 fascinating days, tens of thousands of words were spoken and written trying to divine where the justices stood on the issue. Would the individual mandate be struck down? Would parts of Obamacare be preserved? Would Justice Kennedy be the deciding vote? What judicial horse trading would be necessary for one side to secure 5 votes?
The critical question that emerged once again from these proceedings is why does Justice Thomas never ask any questions during oral arguments? Where are his words?
As everything else that occurs in this town, there is always a political prism that folks peer through. I read one piece suggesting that Republicans win regardless of what the Court decides. If Obamacare is declared constitutionally invalid, then the president is weakened. If the Court upholds the law, then the Republicans can run hard against it in the upcoming election. I don’t agree with this analysis, but this is an example of the drivel that dribbles freely around here.
The truth is, of course, that no one has a clue what the Court will decide. Court watchers know that justices ask questions during oral arguments for many reasons, which may not reflect their views or predict a decision. Yet, predict and pontificate we must. The president had to walk back from his own comments this week, when he opined that the Court should uphold the law, as if the judiciary were not a coequal branch of goverment. Marbury vs Madison anyone?
I’ll make my own prediction here. Readers know that I am hostile to Obamacare. I predict that if the law is upheld, that more and more folks will agree with me as time goes on. Medical costs will continue to rise and medical quality will decline. The medical profession will be suffocated by toxic regulations, restrictions and oversight.
However, I don’t think that the Court should strike down the law just to please me or because the president’s health care law will fail. If you reject judicial activism, then you have do so consistently. It’s not the Court’s job to save a worthy program or to make policy. In my mind, they are charged to answer one question. Is it legal?
Last year, I took the kids to the Supreme Court, and we peered into the chamber where 9 citizens hold enormous power and responsibility. Engraved in the building’s façade are the words, Equal Justice Under Law, an ideal we strive for, but don’t always achieve. Yet, there is no better system.
Thomas Jefferson spent some time in Washington, D.C. also. He was a magician with words, an alchemist who could transform mere words into a harmonious symphony. He wrote to Thomas Paine, another man whose words wielded enormous influence; “Go on doing with your pen what in other times was done with the sword.” Words mattered then, and they still do.
Nice work. I agree, words do matter.
ReplyDeleteSigned,
A debater you probably know quite well
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteSomething had to be done. Here are some basic facts.
ReplyDeleteThe US pay 3 times the world average for health care.
US doctors are the highest paid in the world.
The third leading cause of death in the US are MDs.
The leading cause of death and injury in the US is its health care system.
The odds of getting a nosocomial infections are now one in ten and that is based on a voluntary reporting system.
20% of the US GDP is health care.
The US needs to do what France and Italy are doing for health care.
Medical Tourism from the US is now over one billion a year.
The greedy and deadly American health care industry need to be held accountable. Doctors who over bill should go to jail.
The FDA needs to be dismantled and the the bribe takers should be shot for treason.