MD Whistleblower

Many folks talked about the possibility of an October surprise prior to our recent presidential election.  Rumors swirled of an FBI bombshell, more WikiLeaks or a Russian hack attack.  The predictors were off by a month.  We received instead a November surprise that many view as apocalyptic.  The nation was shocked, as were the candidates, despite Trump’s minions’ confident public exhortations of victory.  How did the press and the punditocracy get it all wrong?   Even days prior to the election, many pollsters were placing Clinton’s chances of victory in the 75-90% range.  An Unexpected Guest We are beginning to understand how a man who has never held elective office, who by all accounts is a boorish and vulgar narcissist, could vanquish 17 Republican adversaries to gain the nomination and then handily trounce the Clinton political machine on November 8th.    The brash outsider prevailed over the consummate insider.   We are beginning to understand why his unending stream

Oftentimes, physicians and patients face bad options.  I wish that the choices that patients faced were all good ones, or at least had one option that was likely to yield a favorable result.   This scenario is further complicated as medicine is an uncertain discipline with moving goal posts and changing facts.  We make decisions and recommendations based on the current state of facts and our medical knowledge and experience.  We may counsel a patient against surgery, only to discover days later in retrospect that an operation would have been the right choice.  An adverse outcome may result from an excellent decision.  There are many medical circumstances when the options are equally foreboding.   A man may be suffering frequent episodes of angina, chest pain caused by hardening of the coronary arteries.  He is on maximal medical treatment, but the symptom persists.  This is not only limiting his life activities and pleasure, but also significantly increases his risk of a heart att

Physicians and patients often face tough and agonizing choices.  Sometimes, there are no good options available.  On other occasions, there are two seemingly reasonable choices in front of you, but there may be a very different outcome from each pathway.  For example, a patient may be advised by a surgeon to submit to the scalpel while the gastroenterologist counsels to opt for another 48 hours hoping that the medical situation will improve.  Which physician is correct?  They both may be right.  If the patient were to deteriorate 24 hours later, then the operation that had been favored by the surgeon would have been the better choice.  If, however, the patient were to improve spontaneously a day or two later, then avoiding high risk surgery would be clearly favored. Physicians make decisions based on knowledge and experience.  Often, there is a conflict between knowledge and experience that physicians struggle to resolve.  For example, a doctor may have read in a medical study tha

Cleveland took a major economic hit a few years back when United Airlines cut most of its flights from our city.  An airport is the heart of a metropolis.  Lack of their direct flights means that business meetings, leisure travel, conventions and trade shows will likely opt for more convenient locales. This was a business decision for United which I am sure was rational.  Nevertheless, their gain was our loss. As a result, we have had several low cost carriers who have swooped in to gain market share.  We have Frontier, Spirit, JetBlue and now Allegiant.  Not a day goes by that I don’t receive an e-mail blast from one of them announcing fares so low that it seems simply not possible.  Many of the flights’ stated fares are less than it would cost me to drive to the destinations.  How do they do it? Of course, the fare price that is stated is not what you will pay.  The total cost of your flight has been fractionated resulting in an a la carte payment system where every additional se

Last week, I offered up an argument on why medical judgement means more than medical knowledge.  In other words, being a really, really smart doctor is not the essential qualification for practicing excellent medicine.  I ended last week’s post with some examples of medical ads that are familiar to all of us.  Here are some ads and slogans that you won’t see on highway billboards or in press advertisements. ·        Bring your back pain to our orthopedists.  They probably won’t operate on you since most back pain is not effectively treated surgically.  You don’t want unnecessary surgery, do you? ·        Wanna lose weight?  Consult with our bariatric surgeons who will refer you to one of our certified dieticians so you can endure yet another diet.  Who wants a trigger happy surgeon anyway? ·        Come to our oncology center for a second opinion.  Don’t expect any new treatments, since ‘promising’ experimental treatments are exactly that – experiments.  We’re not roll

Would you rather that your doctor have excellent medical knowledge or medical judgment?  Answer this question before reading on. Patients are drawn to doctors and medical facilities who boast ‘cutting edge’ medical knowledge and techniques.  Medical judgement, which is much more important in my view, is barely mentioned.  Good doctors have great knowledge, but great doctors have superb judgment.  Consider the following vignette that I hope illustrates why judgement means more than knowledge. A patient is comes to the emergency room with abdominal pain.  The physician refers him to two different physicians, Dr. Knowledge and Dr. Judgment.  Which of these physicians would you rather see? Is the gallbladder the culprit here? Dr. Knowledge:  I recommend that your gallbladder be removed.  I have trained in advanced robotic surgery which leaves only one very small scar.  My complication rate is extremely low.  Our operating room team is excellent.  I am the only surgeon

Years ago, I was having dinner with 2 members of The Cleveland Orchestra, one of the finest orchestras in the world.  I asked them, with my kids present, how much time they devoted to their craft.  As many parents know, getting kids to commit to practicing a musical instrument is about as easy as splitting the atom in your garage.  The musicians told us how much time they practiced, which was mind boggling, as one would expect.  Any artist, athlete, Green Beret or similar professional, has to demonstrate extraordinary commitment to maintain a superlative level of excellence and preparedness. I asked one of the musicians, the violinist, how long he could refrain from playing his instrument before he noted some professional slippage.  Guess your answer.   At the end of this post, I will relate his reply. How many hours are enough? How long can you be away from your job before your performance ebbs?For most of us, we can take weeks or longer on holiday and return back to ou